Sunday, May 31, 2009

Jungles, Waterfalls and Cemeteries

Once I was back there was barely any time to do some real work (although who’s to judge what ‘real’ work is) as we were off on another holiday. I guess once you get into the vagabonder status it’s hard to escape it. So off we were once again to discover the distant corners of north-eastern Cambodia.

The province of Ratanakiri is famous for its milder climate, cultural minorities, crater lakes, fresh waterfalls and numerous plantations – a much needed respite from the touristy and hot Siem Reap. The province is relatively isolated squeezed between Laos and Vietnam and the one road that leads into it is still unpaved (though they are working hard to change that), which keeps the locals in and the tourists out.

There weren’t any particular adventures on the way, for a change, …or maybe it’s our definition of adventure that has changed. Somehow, a 2-day road trip through one of the most remote areas in all of Asia on public transport that at times included 9 people in a compact car (the driver was sharing a seat, i.e. 4 people in the front) just doesn’t seem as shocking as it used to. So the trip was labeled as smooth.

Once there, we were fortunate enough to make a new friend and later be joined by our friends from work, so from a remote getaway that never actualized the week almost immediately turned into a social gathering. The gatherings persisted after we got back to Siem Reap – a clear proof that life at PEPY never stops.

Cambodia - Ratanakiri


Cambodia – Weekends at PEPY and Around

Sunday, May 24, 2009

Another One of Life’s “Firsts”

“When was the last time you did something for the first time?” Such is the moto of Emirates Airlines and here they were, whisking a diverse group of Emirates away from their home and towards the unknown, somewhat mysterious adventure beyond. Full of enthusiasm and idealistic dreams they were unaware that for most of them this experience was about to become their ‘first’ same as it was going to become for me. First time we performed hard labour on a construction site, first time we built a future for someone we haven’t even met.

This trip was part of PEPY’s collaboration with Dubai Cares – an Emirate NGO, to build three primary schools in rural Siem Reap province. Over the course of a month four teams of volunteers from Dubai joined PEPY in Cambodia to help construct these schools as well as learn about sustainable development. PEPY has been getting ready for these trips for over half a year and been waiting for the teams with trepidation wondering how the participants would fare when they arrived. And finally here they were, as our founder Daniela describes it:

“Off the plane they came […] adorned with bright make up and their clothes sparkled as they each waited to purchase their Cambodian sim-cards at the airport mobile phone counter. […] Rather than turn left on the main road out of the airport, towards the Disneyland-esque town of Siem Reap where new hotel monstrosities line the roads and poverty is hidden from view, we turned right and took [them] straight to [a rural village of] Kralanh to a house we had rented a section of for the [trips].”

In the weeks that followed we witnessed the greatest transformation in a time period so short one hour was different from the one before it. From make-up and designer wear-clad crowd participants quickly took form of sweaty construction laborers working 8 hour shifts in the heat of a blistering sun; from carrying designer bags they went to carrying baskets of dirt and sand; from riding in fancy sports cars they suddenly found themselves in the back of a pick-up truck on bumpy, rocky and muddy Cambodian roads; and from residing in air-conditioned lavish housing they were now sleeping in muggy, bug-infested quarters that they shared with each other. But the complaints were few as everyone saw the bigger picture that it is only when the lifestyle is stripped off its overstated luxuries and pretentiousness to the very bare bones that one’s mind can really be receptive to the concepts of compassion and benevolence towards less fortunate than one’s self.

The transformations came in many forms and did not just affect the participants. The local community’s behaviours and comfort zones were evolving at lightning speed to adjust to the new, never before seen surroundings. The first day we arrived we went for a walk around the village we were going to help build the school for. For most of the village’s population we were the first westerners they have ever came across, none the least interacted. The kids were especially vulnerable. Most treated us with a look that was a mixture of perplexed, terrified and curious, the kind we’d have if we saw a group of aliens land and then break into a boogie.

Over the next few days their different personalities really shone as they grew accustomed to us. Some remained terrified and maintained a radius around us (which was shrinking as days went by), others let their curiosity take over and dove right into it letting us play and interact with them (to the bedazzled looks of their less gutsy peers). Only selected few got comfortable enough to work and play close to us but almost all showed up at the construction site every day regardless. Unable to resist their curiosity and infatuated with these new people that suddenly appeared in their lives they came to gawk and in between lend a hand with the construction of their future school.

Even the terrified ones, as much as they were scared, couldn’t resist it the day the art supplies were brought in. In a culture where individuality and creativity are not encouraged and in a place where the kids never as much as drew a picture or held crayons in their hands, colourful construction paper, glue and most importantly the people who were happy to give their time teaching how to use it all, were better than any candy. A whole village of bewildered kids went into a craze with the art projects.

Along with the kids came adult volunteers to lend a hand with the construction. On the first day 14 volunteers showed up and worked hard the whole shift. In fact it was impossible to tell who was paid and who wasn’t. At the end we were shocked to discover that only 8 out of the couple dozens of locals were officially employed. Everyone else just really wanted the school to be built.

After a day of hard work, feeling accomplished all of us: trip participants and PEPY trip leaders headed back to our temporary home where we would try to make sense of everything we’ve seen and learned that day. While most days were enchanting they were also exhausting, filled with contrasting emotions and rivers of sweat (as well as tears for some). Some were so emotionally straining that people couldn’t help but let their emotions take hold of them. At times it didn’t really sink in until you saw an otherwise macho-like men trying to quietly hide their tearing eyes.

To the sound of millions of crickets, passing motos and gangs of barking dogs, to the soft brushes of the gentle breeze and the persistent attack of nocturnal bugs, surrounded by the warm and muggy tropical night, palm-dotted cambodian countryside and a group of inspiring people - this was the time for self doubt. Why am I here? What am I trying to achieve? Am I doing this to satisfy my Western guilt or are local people actually benefiting from my work? These were the dilemmas that tortured many of our participants’ minds and kept them up at night. PEPY’s core objective was to encourage that line of thought, to make people scrutinize the feel-good work they get involved it, be it their own work or the work of the NGOs they donate to (not the keeping them up at night part, that’s just a side-effect ;) ).

As channel 1 of UAE later reported (and most of PEPY staff already new), most participants labeled this experience as “life-changing” or “eye-opening”. Not in a million years could one imagine the complexities and the politics of the philanthropic world until one really goes out there and gets involved with it. As many industries before them, NGOs and voluntourism have evolved to such scale, complexity and power these days, that it becomes particularly important to take time to really understand what makes right from wrong. There are many players but not all, unfortunately, are genuine and even the ones that are do not always take their time to learn what’s best for their subjects.

Such was the lesson that I took from this trip as well as working here. I don’t know if our projects are very sustainable or if our work is as beneficial as it could be. I sure hope that to some extent they are but I’m not going to claim that PEPY is the most exemplary role model in the NGO and voluntourism worlds. All I know right now is that these are still evolving industries and there remains much to be learned; all we can do is observe, take note on what had worked and what didn’t, acknowledge the mistakes and continuously improve. And in the end, we might still never learn the answers. This is a story of compassion and change, a story of self doubt and a whole lot of hard work.

Cambodia - Dubai Cares Trip

Politics of Philanthropy

There are four core types of foreigners in Cambodia:
1. Stereotypical Angkor tourists that fly in to see the temples and get out 2.3 days later (official statistic of an average tourist)
2. Indiana Johnes wannabes that think themselves to be the toughest and most daring traveler around just for including Cambodia on their itinerary (while doing little more than following a typical tourist trail)
3. Sex tourists – the dodgy middle-aged men creeping into the country where women are uneducated and desperate because no sane Western woman would even look at them
4. Philanthropists that come here to change the world

What the last two have in common is that they come here out of passion be it for pervasive sexual relationships or human welfare. Despite the obvious differences even philanthropists may actually be detrimental to the country's wellbeing.

While passion is necessary, it alone is not enough to make aid effective. In fact, acting entirely out of heart and much less out of thought can seldom yield anything of value. This is how people end up building schools where there is no qualified staff to fill them or teaching english when the kids are illiterate in their local language all the while being convinced that they are making a major difference in local people's lives....and they definitely are – by taking away jobs that would otherwise be filled by local people while deepening their dependence on foreign aid.

Cambodia has one of the highest number of NGOs per capita in the world yet it is not showing signs of extensive progress. Why not? Because many are doing it wrong, and it seems like almost every new one is there just to repeat the mistakes of its ancestors not to improve on them.

Many NGOs operate by the 'see the problem – fix the problem morale'. See a hungry street kid, feel bad – shove him into some orphanage quickly, feel good – immediate gratification. See another one the next day – shove him there as well, repeat the procedure till space runs out, then open a new orphanage and keep doing so indefinitely all the while feeling good about yourself and the fact that another kid is no longer hungry. What about the next kid and the one after? How long can one really keep this up?

While the deed is touching it is hardly sustainable. Instead, you ought to ask yourself: are you really addressing the problem at its source and investing in a long-term solution or are you just making a quick fix? Are you helping the community to solve a problem as part of their initiative or are you trying to solve it all for them?

While some NGOs busy themselves creating short-lived unsustainable solutions others pour enormous resources into grand long-term entire-country-revamp type solutions that only work in theory but seldom in practice. Such is the case with many governments and international development organizations such us World bank and IMF that fund billion- dollar solutions that a) are culturally-insensitive and are based on “Western experience” and hence do not actually work for other countries; b) are not monitored or evaluated in the process of execution as well as during the outcomes stage, resulting in no motivation to achieve the set goals; c) are conditional on some political mumbo-jumbo that benefits the West and yields more damage than good; d) are reliant on co-operation of local corrupt officials that make sure the money never reaches the ones it was intended for.

What’s the solution? If I knew I wouldn’t be here in Cambodia writing a cheesy blog. My point of writing this entry is not to tell those who’ve seen and done it all how to do it better but rather to offer some food for thought and spark some interest in this matter among those that did not have a chance to get a close look.