Sunday, May 24, 2009

Politics of Philanthropy

There are four core types of foreigners in Cambodia:
1. Stereotypical Angkor tourists that fly in to see the temples and get out 2.3 days later (official statistic of an average tourist)
2. Indiana Johnes wannabes that think themselves to be the toughest and most daring traveler around just for including Cambodia on their itinerary (while doing little more than following a typical tourist trail)
3. Sex tourists – the dodgy middle-aged men creeping into the country where women are uneducated and desperate because no sane Western woman would even look at them
4. Philanthropists that come here to change the world

What the last two have in common is that they come here out of passion be it for pervasive sexual relationships or human welfare. Despite the obvious differences even philanthropists may actually be detrimental to the country's wellbeing.

While passion is necessary, it alone is not enough to make aid effective. In fact, acting entirely out of heart and much less out of thought can seldom yield anything of value. This is how people end up building schools where there is no qualified staff to fill them or teaching english when the kids are illiterate in their local language all the while being convinced that they are making a major difference in local people's lives....and they definitely are – by taking away jobs that would otherwise be filled by local people while deepening their dependence on foreign aid.

Cambodia has one of the highest number of NGOs per capita in the world yet it is not showing signs of extensive progress. Why not? Because many are doing it wrong, and it seems like almost every new one is there just to repeat the mistakes of its ancestors not to improve on them.

Many NGOs operate by the 'see the problem – fix the problem morale'. See a hungry street kid, feel bad – shove him into some orphanage quickly, feel good – immediate gratification. See another one the next day – shove him there as well, repeat the procedure till space runs out, then open a new orphanage and keep doing so indefinitely all the while feeling good about yourself and the fact that another kid is no longer hungry. What about the next kid and the one after? How long can one really keep this up?

While the deed is touching it is hardly sustainable. Instead, you ought to ask yourself: are you really addressing the problem at its source and investing in a long-term solution or are you just making a quick fix? Are you helping the community to solve a problem as part of their initiative or are you trying to solve it all for them?

While some NGOs busy themselves creating short-lived unsustainable solutions others pour enormous resources into grand long-term entire-country-revamp type solutions that only work in theory but seldom in practice. Such is the case with many governments and international development organizations such us World bank and IMF that fund billion- dollar solutions that a) are culturally-insensitive and are based on “Western experience” and hence do not actually work for other countries; b) are not monitored or evaluated in the process of execution as well as during the outcomes stage, resulting in no motivation to achieve the set goals; c) are conditional on some political mumbo-jumbo that benefits the West and yields more damage than good; d) are reliant on co-operation of local corrupt officials that make sure the money never reaches the ones it was intended for.

What’s the solution? If I knew I wouldn’t be here in Cambodia writing a cheesy blog. My point of writing this entry is not to tell those who’ve seen and done it all how to do it better but rather to offer some food for thought and spark some interest in this matter among those that did not have a chance to get a close look.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

I challenge Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie to spend the obscene reserves held by their 'Jolie-Pitt' Foundation on legitimate efficient 'humanitarian' work or turn the funds over to others who will. To date, they have taken in $22,000,000 on the sale of baby photos alone, another 6 or 7 figures from other sources, and spent or granted only a fraction of that on 'humanitarian' work or 'good will' of any kind. The rest so far, has been spent on PR campaigns, plane rides, and super-high end accomodations for Brad and Angie in exotic locations around the world. I challenge them to meet the criteria of a legitimate charity, operate with a reasonable overhead, open their books to prove it, and get their 'foundation' worthy of a decent rating by an independent watchdog like Charitywatch.org. Otherwise, to stop selling baby photos for their own 'charity' and stop seeking publicity for donations made in their own name to their own foundation/travel/PR firm shortly before or after the premier of their latest film or DVD release. I challenge Brad Pitt to do the same with his 'Make it right' Foundation. Which to date, has not met the criteria of a legitimate charity or been given a decent rating by ANY independent charity watchdog. Otherwise, to stop competing with 'Habitat for Humanity' for PR, credit, and funding. Who by the way have been building homes for the less fortunate in every major city including New Orleans for decades. 'Habitat for Humanity' has been 'Top Rated' for years by charitywatch.org and others. They operate with a low overhead, volunteer workforce, and donated materials. No similar effort can match their progress hour for hour or dollar for dollar. They don't even come close. Unlike 'Make it right', the homes built by 'Habitat' don't sit vacant. They don't exclude by cost, lower income families. They are allocated and built specifically for the less fortunate who take part in the building process and move in immediately upon completion. 'Habitat' works in every major city including New Orleans. It puts 'Make it right' to shame. In fact, hundreds of legitimate charities have been given good-excellent ratings by Charitywatch.org and other independent watchdog groups. By contrast, the vast, overwhelming majority of celebrity 'foundations' have been rated poorly, fair, or not rated at all. They are inefficient, corrupt, focus heavily on PR, and operate with shady, self-serving, misleading accounting practices. They usually don't even meet the criteria of a legitimate charity. Still, they have the nerve to self-audit, self-praise, mislead the donor/fan base, seek funding from a number of sources including ordinary people, compete with legitimate charities, and cash in on maximum PR for their inefficient 'humanitarian' efforts. Its not right.

Unknown said...

Excellent entry. I have actually had this conversation multiple times lately... such a touch topic.

Anna Baranova said...

my topic or the guy's above? cause we are on a somewhat different page here. :)

The topic is a tough one. I can't figure it out for myself either, so many things to consider and an industry where there is just too much 'heart' and 'emotion' to think clearly and be unbiased in your decisions, yields many flawed convictions.